First Team:
P - Billy Wagner, Ferrum
P - Kyle Weaver, Longwood
P - Mark Matthews, Mary Washington
C - Tim Madden, Mary Washington
1B - Jerold Smith, Ferrum
2B - Anthony Doane, Virginia Wesleyan
3B - Terry Taylor, Longwood
SS - Steve Blankenship, Mary Washington
OF - Don Purcell, Mary Washington
OF - Bill Harlow, Bridgewater
OF - Shawn Jones, Longwood
DH - Brian Abel, Mary Washington

Honorable Mention:
Elly Bratton, Christopher Newport
Keith Mayhew, Ferrum
Jason Wilson, Ferrum
Chris Tyson, Longwood
Jeff Toms, Longwood
Brian Bassett, Longwood
Jim Ciarlo, Lynchburg
TJ Williams, Virginia State
Doug Kaufman, Virginia Wesleyan
Jayson Humrich, Virginia Wesleyan